BEFORE: SPOKEN LECTURE TRANSCRIPT Source transcript passages transformed into the companion Study Ready example. The Study Ready version reorganises the same information into a clearer structure. Section 119 deals with confidential communications and documents prepared for the dominant purpose of a client being provided with professional legal services relating to an Australian or overseas proceeding, including anticipated or pending proceedings. Now, do not collapse the statutory and common law questions into each other. In Esso the High Court was considering the common law test in the context of discovery, but the existence of the Evidence Act formed part of the legal landscape. The Court ultimately held that the common law should also use the dominant purpose test. So Esso displaced the sole purpose test from Grant v Downs. That is the headline. The correct common law test became the dominant purpose test. What does dominant purpose actually mean? It means that the legal purpose does not have to be the only purpose. There can be other purposes. But the purpose of obtaining legal advice, or obtaining legal services in relation to litigation, must be the ruling, prevailing or dominant purpose. The High Court in Esso also made clear that purpose is to be objectively determined, although evidence of a person’s subjective purpose can be highly relevant and may be decisive. That becomes important in practice because organisations often try to establish purpose through evidence about why a document was commissioned, who requested it, what instructions were given, who received it, and what was happening at the time. But labels are not magic. Writing “privileged and confidential” at the top of a document does not itself create privilege. Sending a document to a lawyer does not necessarily create privilege. Copying a lawyer into an email does not necessarily create privilege. You need to look at the substance of the communication and why it came into existence. Now let us put Grant v Downs and Esso side by side because this is where the doctrinal development becomes much easier to remember. Grant v Downs, 1976: majority adopts sole purpose. Esso, 1999: High Court adopts dominant purpose at common law. So if you are answering a contemporary Australian common law problem, Esso is the authority you should be thinking about for the test. Grant v Downs remains important because it explains the earlier position and, importantly, because Barwick CJ’s minority reasoning anticipated the approach the Court later adopted. Raw transcript source material — intentionally speech-like. The companion page shows these same passages after ScribeBloc restructuring.